Biological Males Should Not Compete in Women’s Sports (Part 1) | Change My Mind

They should have a separate sport for trans athletes. Like they do with the special Olympics.

0:26, finally. It’s been a while since we had one of those

The whole usa soccer team was ass kicked by teenagers, who they won world cup i believe

See this is the problem with the leftists and the reason they throw things refuse to speak and attempt to shout you down, they can’t rationalize their opinions they cant make a convincing enough argument to change your mind that’s why they use violence.

Where are the biological women competing in men's sports? No outcry for this yet? Seems awfully one sided of the left. So one sided, it almost seems like a targeted matter

Remember the kid from Jungle Book? Yeah, this is him now. Feel old yet?

Anybody else notice the hyuk hyuk hyuk hyuk laugh?? 😆 🤣 😂

This guy's honest, but his argument is based upon his feelings about "fairness" with men "identifying as women" who want to compete against "other women," but he's dismissing ALL of the objective facts which say that "trans women" competing against biological Women is UNFAIR and even dangerous to them. His entire argument is competely flawed.

I wonder, for anyone who agrees with Isaac, are you satisfied with his argument?
Because I thought Isaac seems pretty educated and also did a good job of not backing down, asked questions before replying, restated his points, basically followed the general rule book of debate, I’m interested if his argument spoke to anyone or made then reconsider or validate their own position.
I think that because Isaac did a good job debating, but failed to help me consider his position in any way, I’m more confidently planted in my position (nearly identical to S.C.) on this subject.
And I was really trying to take the Devil’s advocate approach through the entire interview.

Why these conversations peak over 10 seconds, is beyond me.

If trans female to male cant logically compete Vs biological males, why can trans male to females compete Vs biological females? Doesnt make sense and contradicts their whole argument. Why not just start with that….

Hold up. Even as a left leaning independent. There is no way in hell any trans athlete should be playing female sports. You have significant physical advantages going through puberty as a male regardless of your current “gender identity “.

he won the first medal then was ordered to slow down

Finaly a new ''change my mind episode''
In the future when its cheaper and easyer to switch your genders ect, its gonna be a man vs genders and the woman will be left out.
If its getting a problem already that trans people dominate the female devision, than it might be best to make a 3rd devision voor trans people.
Its completely unfair for bio woman that have worked there whole life to finaly reach the top of the woman devision. just to get there ass beat by trans or on there way to the top.
i would't be surprised if in the future, the top 100 would excist out 50/50 woman and trans, witch basicly get ruled by trans as there is a much lower % of trans in sport than excual female.

When the kid said he wasn’t an expert on the subject…he was either trying to be humble about his lack of expertise, or trying to back out of a corner. But regardless….

We’re not talking about rocket science or even algebra. We’re talking about what defines a man, and what defines a woman, and what the real world consequences of those definitions are. A 5 year old has a basic grasp of this. This is something every human absolutely understands because it is it is a fundamental aspect of EVERY human’s experience, since the beginning of man. The intellectual leftists want to act like it’s some highly complicated, individually unique experience. It’s…..not. That’s like saying that because you didn’t go to law school, you can’t understand that it’s illegal to steal a car or run a red light. Or if you aren’t a professional chef, you can’t fry bacon and eggs. Some things are basic to human existence. If you can’t define what a man or woman is, then neither mean anything. But they do mean something.

Kid is out of his mind, but at least he is able to have a respectful conversation instead of screaming racist nazi to everything that moves.

At this point these woke people have seriously made me actually support Hitler.

Just an idea.
Allow Trans athletes to compete BUT Handicap them with weights like horse racing, based upon their previous performances.

Otherwise this whole subject becomes seriously cyclical…
It's almost like choosing between a having a mind or a body.
I agree with both of them, Steven AND the guy in the beany hat. The young fella is extremely mindful and shows a great deal of emotional intelligence & empathy for somebody of his age. The only way to make the system ungameable is to introduce a handicap on trans athletes to stop the ridiculous gulfs in records.