Vinay Prasad MD MPH
Vinay Prasad, MD MPH; Physician & Associate Professor
Google Scholar: https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=ym4rwk0AAAAJ&hl=en
Substack: https://vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/
Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/plenary-session/id1429998903
Personal Website: www.vinayakkprasad.com
Laboratory Website: www.vkprasadlab.com
Podcast Website: www.plenarysessionpodcast.com
Academic Publications: http://www.vinayakkprasad.com/papers
Follow me on:
Twitter @vprasadmdmph
00:00 Recommending Omicron boosters for all.
01:00 Data To support BA.4/5
01:46 Simplicity, one size fits all
02:12 Out of simplicity we dont just give everyone chemotherapy
02:34 Level of evidence different for 90 yo aged care to 20 yr athlete
03:36 Mouse data not sufficient
03:50 Millions of people have had BA4/5
04:20 CDC "There's no wrong time to get a booster
04:40 It is clear the companies have a corporate interest here
THE CORPORATE INTEREST IS TO HAVE A YEARLY SHOT.
04:57 Achieved a regulatory standard via influenza
05:03 Allow imunogenicity data from animals to be used for human approved
05:15 Maybe we should be asking better questions about flu vax
05:40 History of medicine and powerful important people creating regulatory standards
06:20 since 1960 Have improved the conduct of randomized trials
06:30 Vinays Polls, Who gets the vax, scenarios
07:08 Getting the right answers
07:30 Risk of shots diminished as older up side greater
07:45 Even there, not impossible to run a randomized controlled trial
08:00 A pragmatic control trial design
08:07 What we're forgetting TRANSMISSION IS NOT GOING TO BE HALTED BY THE NEW BOOSTER
08:16 BECAUSE NONE OF THE OTHER VARIANTS WERE
08:20 Variant escape from the new thing OTHERWISE THE YEARLY BOOSTER MODEL FLOPS
08:25 Peter Marx(ist the fascist) has written that in JAMA
08:30 THE GOAL OF THIS VACCINE IS TO LOWER THE RISK OF SEVERE DISEASE HOSPITALISATION
08:35 Back to the (FUNDEMENTALLY FLAWED) OBSERVATIONAL STUDIES as proof
08:40 All Biased due to Vax cult "me first" types healthier and wealthier at base line
08:55 curves for mortality seperate faster than it takes the 7 to 10 days for vax to take effect
09:09 The health "VACCINE ME" effect
09:20 BIASES are SO STRONG you CANNOT EXCEPT OBSERVATIONAL STUDIES
09:25 YOU NEED RANDOMIZED CONTROL TRIALS (**AND DIRECT CHALLENGE STUDIES** screw this hiding behind ethics BS fraud)
09:40 Paul Offit And Vinay agree THE YOUNG DONT NEED BOOSTER
09:44 It reckless and dangerous to prove it for the young
09:48 Rational of one size fits all IS REALLY STUPID
10:23 The loss of rational voice Gruber And Crause from the FDA had PRINCIPAL AND INTEGRITY
10:35 Peter Marx(ist fascist) seems to be taking his ques from government
10:40 not just this one, ANY WHITE-HOUSE
10:46 Agenda is not solely for the BETTERMENT OF HEALTH OF THE PEOPLE
10:53 May have corporate capture (fascists)
11:00 Political donations, post public role employment
11:12 The revolving door of individuals
11:15 FDA commisioner > pfharma consulting; Scott Gotlieb FDA comisioner now board of pfizerfraud; Steve Harn capital venture with intersts in moderna
11:29 where will they go ? Bob Caitlif, Ashish Jar ????
11:36 Whitehouse Tsar will he work for a company he interacted with in public position ???
11:40 TSAR Definition; Power wielding person who is not subject to the rules
11:52 WHERE WILL ROCHELLE WOLYINSKI GO???
11:58 All not clear regulators, not evidence based people pre pandemic not know as rigorous thinkers
12:12 Many published retrospective dubious admin data analysis. You are what you practiced
12:29 Political calculus; What do we want When do we want it before the mid terms to make us look good
12:45 PUBLIC HEALTH IS ABOUT THE WELL BEING OF THE PEOPLE AT *ANY* MOMENT IN TIME
12:49 What can we do ? This is Extremely important issue in the history of medicine
13:00 Are we going to allow Universities to mandate this product ?
13:05 IT SHOULD NOT BE MANDATED
13:05 I WOULD ENCOURAGE LEGAL FORCES
TO DENY PRIVATE ACTOR THE POWER TO MANDATE VACCINES THAT COME TO MARKET WITH SO MUCH UNCERTAINTY
13:15 Wake force universities acting before they know human data on punishment of dis-enrollment
DO WE SERIOUSLY LIVE IN THIS COUNTRY THAT ALLOWS THIS ????
16:35 Employers should not be allowed to mandate it. Laws to stop them playing doctor.
14:00 No justification DOES NOT STOP INFECTION or SPREAD in organizations to save the "cant be vaxd"
14:15 NO 3rd PARTY BENEFIT RATIONALE
14:20 Last arguments; your individual health benefits; are we comfortable with that reach?
14:35 Can an employer tell me what to eat at home ???
14:45 As a 20 yr old man my diet might have more to do with my health than whether i get the n th Dose which has marginal, zero or no benefit at all
14:56 Long term morbidity and mortality there is no data
15:00 Terminating fat people who dont adhere to employer mandated diets ??
Whats next in this dangerous space.
15:15 Makes no sense; CONTRARY TO AMERICAN VALUES and LEGALITY SHOULD BE QUESTIONED
15:23 I JUST KNOW ITS BAD MEDICINE MANDATES SHOULD BE USED SPARINGLY, (like eczema cream.) WHEN THE 3rd PARTY BENEFIT OUTWEIGHS THE LOSS OF AUTONOMY to the individual
15:33 Was never met with any of these vaccines, certainly not one that was only given to 8 mice
15:38 The FDA is delinquent; creating the worst system imaginable
15:48 Not having meaningful regulatory standards of safety and efficacy
16:10 FDA is at sweet spot for profit, worst spot for public health
16:20 COVID-19 ??? is going to ravage young children HCHIF speaker ??
16:58 YOU ARE FEAR MONGERING re kids should you even be on this panel
17:15 We dont have US data but this is what Ontario says. WE ARE BOTH HUMAN BEINGS
17:45 Can vax or boosting lower long covid ? Whats the definition?
18:09 If it appear in NMWR you are going to want to read it twice
18:36 THE "DO GOODERS" with LOW CREDIBILITY EVIDENCE are LOW CREDIBILITY PEOPLE SHOULD BE TREATED as such
18:40 Just like the definate nay Sayers are low credibility
19:00 A spectum of response due to the lack of RCTs ie "STRATIFIED"
19:15 Guber And Crause, right choice for THEM to resign but not for the rest of us
WE NEEDED THEM TO PUSH BACK
19:27 over reach by the white house and its a dangerous game; most dont realize just how dangerous
19:40 And they dont see that they are playing with fire hear.
Thank you Vinay Prasad
This is a pretty poor indictment. And after all that you still want to believe that fascism is not a wound deep in the heart of the Empire, if you still want to believe that somewhere Ole "Lets Go" Joe, and Fauci, and all those other names, deep down have your health and best interests at heart, for them to have got it this wrong, for them to push things to this limit,
then the only thing you can infer is that THEY KNOW THAT Peter Daszak had a hand in this being made in a Chyna BSL2 and it was an accidental leak.
And if you have lost all faith, then this so called march of mandates can only be the result it was a deliberately manufactured bio-weapon.
How could they otherwise be so adamant in their stubborn wrongness.
So you are starting to notice the CDC is not acting out of good faith.. you think its a new phenomena just for the boosters? It's been so from day 01 for the very first shot, an inconvenient truth you choose to continue to ignore at a great cost for humanity.
Dr. Prasad,
My wife has been an ER nurse for the past 8 years. She was working at a hospital near Arizona State University in November of 2019 when the hospital was inundated with young people coming into the ER with Flu-like Symptoms, but whom all tested negative for the actual flu. That same month, she got sick and spread that to me. Not going to lie, I think that was the worst I’ve ever been sick (that I can recall) in all my 50 years on this planet.
Since then, she has worked at several ERs in AZ and then in Houston Texas, including all through the worst of the pandemic. We both received the original Pfizer vaccine but have not had any boosters. I can’t recall being symptomatic at any time since that time in late 2019 but cannot see a way that we have not since been exposed. I’m hesitant to get boosters at this point since everyone I know that have been double boosted, have still gotten “breakthrough” covid-all without even passing it to their spouses.
Bwaaaahahaha 😝 Don't start, then you won't need a perpetual "booster(s)"
But what about the flu vaccine not having human data on a yearly basis? Are you against the recommendations of yearly flu shots too?
Meanwhile I have to wonder about the other 20% or whatever extreme who are going to think like this: Federal funding for vaccines will supposedly run out in December 2022, so how about get a Pfizer Omicron booster ASAP and also get the Moderna booster in December! Cross boostering is now said to be perfectly fine. So the supply of vaccine may be surprisingly both halved and ignored by most people.
Only fear and power will keep the sheep under control. A population of sheep begets a government of wolves.
Yet another red flag to add to the growing pile.
I think if anyone mandates that new bivalent booster they should at least be decent enough to give out a piece of cheese with every shoot.
For a cold.
You are so right.
Pol Pot was right.
So, you haven't realized that it was never about the science? It's about the money…
They won't let me work because I have health problems ,this is all lies and governments are getting sued and are going to pay ridiculous one big scam and people dying everywhere.
Corporate interests are only financial interests. F Big Pharma and the politicians that bow to them, instead of the science.
Yes sir, thank you for your videos. I am glad you are bold enough to communicate a dialogue about all of these issues.
ygtbsm
I fear that my son's college will mandate this booster. Here in America, in 2022, a father may have to pull his son from a university because the people running the school have lost their collective minds. I pray that it doesn't come to that. But what do I tell my son when I pull him out of his school? I've never wished to be a billionaire, but I do now. Just so I can sue the hell out Massachusetts who are mandating this. And sue the hell out of universities that cares more about virtue signaling and going against Trump than they do caring about their student body. Here we are, in the US, in 2022. @19:20 Maybe you can ask Dr. Offit to ask Grueber/Krause to come on your VPZD podcast. One of the best out there!
Sometimes i get so depressed that i feel like taking a ooster just to end it all.
Love your shit
VP, I say it every time, you are the man!! I could watch you every day, keep up the good work. You are on the right side of history, everyone on the other side, well, let's just say it won't be a good look.
He’s getting there. Red pill in process.
in canada they want it now every 90 days ahahahahahahaah
Vinay — you da man^H^H^H penile-person! Keep up the great work.
The business of believing dubious observational studies seems to pay pretty good.
This guy is pro.
Can you believe this crap? How can we as physicians tolerate that the CDC spew this kind idiocy?
And what percentage of present say infections are Alpha? Pretty much 0%!
i recomend the CDC to stfu
CDC recommends the new product of Pfizer etc…Because Pfizer pay them millions per year in funding. The same with every politician, FDA, NIH and law maker.
next one will be within mounth and the next on one after 2 weeks… soon one everyday.. does not give much room,,,,,
This whole thing will surely backfiring on these companies. I went from taking the usual vaccines without question prior to the pandemic to not trusting just about anything that comes from these companies. I’m sure they turned many people into anti vaxxers because of the complete lack of integrity. Trust is gone now.
The thought of people repeatedly injecting themselves with these experimental drugs makes me nauseous!
Maybe people should remember that God determines your dying day, nothing you do will change this.
the vaccine is contrary to good science!
I just started grad school this week and my college is mandating boosters… in the past all nursing students are not allowed any exemption except medical only, but I just received an email from the Dean to prepare for medical exemptions to go away. Yes… that means they plan to force a student to boost against medical advice and discriminate against a person’s medical condition. How is this safe and ethical?
"im so gutted i didn't get the covid vax" said nobody ever
The one size fits all policy includes increasing profits regardless of the costs, thanks for the video.
Bang on again professor
Great, but this was obvious from the start. We needed this voice then.
All mandated/forced/coerced vaccines should be made illegal. It's disgusting what these people think they should be allowed to control!
Why are colleges making my student test weekly if a vaccinated student can give and get it too? And no they are not experiencing less severe symptoms. Shouldn't logically all be tested? You would think with all the mask wearing less would be affected by all the gaslighting.
There should be no controversy on this topic! What is being said here makes sense, the counter to this simply does not make sense. What the hell is there to debate?!
How stupid do they think we are? No fucking way any these poison shitzines!!!
Everybody thinks they are immuno-compromised these days, yet statistically zero people under 50 are dying “from” Covid. That’s a problem.
Saying the CDC is recommending a booster is the same as saying Big Pharma is recommending a booster, because they're one and the same.
Thank you so much for everything you do.
I believe many of us do know just how dangerous this can be and is proving to be.