Why Do Socialists Hate Charity?

I’ll just give nothing at all, if that’s how you’re gonna act!


Join the community discord! ►
Watch Us LIVE (And Click Dat Sub Button!) ►

GB Archive Channel ►
Dev Kit Channel ►
SFO Backups Channel ►




SubscribeStar! ►
Streamlabs! ►
Patreon! ►
Paypal! ►

Humble Bundle Affiliate Link! ►
Amazon CAN Affiliate Link! ►
Amazon USA Affiliate Link! ►
Amazon CAN Wishlist! ►
Amazon USA Wishlist! ►





Thumbnail ► solidarity, not charity
Background ►
Music ►

#Solidarity #charity #MutualAid

Written by ShortFatOtaku

Hi, I'm SFO, and on this channel I make political and philosophical content. There's a lot wrong with the world at the moment, and I don't really have any way to affect political change other than making videos on pertinent topics, so I'll do what I can. My political position is a liberal centrist - I believe that free western capitalist democracy is the best political system we have, and that it's under attack from all sides, from SJWs, from religious extremism, from radical feminism, from identitarianism, from both progressivism and regressivism, from extremism from both ends of the political spectrum. If you're expecting me to either be alt-right, or side with social justice, you're going to be very disappointed.


Leave a Reply
  1. but Dev everything for the state & nothing outside of the state!
    ~some idiot ive heard way too much of online

    Great Topic well done.
    Another Based Destiny clip ill now go watch too later.
    Also Dev this why i cringed at your claim we should love the Queen because she loves every citizen equally. The state is not your mother or father & you should not treat them as such.
    PS The Russian cope is growing might want to put it on the docket before everyone starts deleting they're anti Ukrainian & Russia stronk posts.

  2. Fantastic vid, This vid makes me appreciate zakat and sadaqah in Islam even more, 2.5% of your wealth earned in a year given as religious obligation that goes towards the poor and needy, freeing captives and slaves, stranded wayfarers, etc. Alongside the voluntary charity of Sadaqah, it really is the middle path between the two extremes present within modern day capitalism and whatever form communism has taken at this present moment.

  3. So in other words, the difference between charity and solidarity, in the socialists minds, is that charity is giving something without expecting anything in return, while solidarity is giving something while expecting something in return, meaning that socialists want to give to to poor with the expectation that the poor will give the socialists their loyalty and support in return, which is what the socialists really want.

  4. I had to pause and yell at the screen at that clueless shit arguing with Destiny.

    Why does it have to be transactional, buddy all you socialist shits do is transactional, everything has to be how it benefits your little social groups terrible fucking ideas.

    Solidarity not charity? You don't even want solidarity unless it's within your deluded fucking disasterous ideology written by a parasitic loser on his buddies couch

    And the statement that the ideology is more important than food is the crowning of the shit cake.

    Jesus fucking god you may as well be a legion of Marie-Antonnetes spewing "let them eat cake"

  5. I'm against charity too. Most charities are scams and it's not a real way to help anyone otherwise you would hear a lot more about charities being shut down not even more charities being created.

  6. On the surface I understand it many Charities just throw money at problems in vain hopes that the problem will go away. Solidarity and understanding sounds like better understanding of a problem and actually doing an honest effort to solve the problem. Instead of just throwing money to a community you actually build a community garden

  7. I am from both DGG and you SFO, the dead queen bless you both for keeping some semblance of sanity with the worst of the right and left hating y'all. Also I pray for a Collab at some point 🙏🙏

  8. As you said, commies do not care about the poor. They hate the rich.

    With that said, there is a hell of a case to have mutual aid societies rather than the welfare state. I say this as AnCap.

  9. All socialist theory comes back to: “someone needs to be given power and authority, and that somebody just happens to be me” everything else is just post hoc justification for them to seize or be given authority over others.

  10. The source of Christian Charity is more that wealth is a gift from god and when times are good you should spread it in his name. The motivation is more spreading gods influence through action and faith.

    Your also not suppose to value the material, so the act of charity can also keep your greed in check.

    Guilt cannot be lifted through acts alone, Christians do absolutions. Protestants pray for forgiveness, Catholics do confessionals, flaggelatents whip themselves, etc etc.

    Now personally is a different question however.

  11. My main problem with this idea is that "shared interest" part, it means that as long as you agree with your betters, you'll get food, shelter and clothing, but the second you deviate from it, you're no longer part of the community, no longer part of the "struggle", you're just another dissident that will break the system and it's just to remove you from it, since you are no longer one of "them".

  12. Socialists are too selfish and out of touch with reality to care about charity. Why would they spend their own time and resources to help someone else when they can just do nothing but say words and claim that's helping those people?

  13. You can tell it’s communism/socialism. Every aspect, every institution, every person has to be under one idea for it to run.
    Sounds authoritarian to me.
    I remember my communist phase, then I graduated high school.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.